Challenging The Validity Of The Will

Challenging The Validity Of The Will

Sanskar Raj Singh_JudicateMe


This Blog is written by Sanskar Raj Singh from Lloyd Law College, Greater NoidaEdited by Maulika Awasthi.



A will is a legal document that sets forth your wishes regarding the distribution of your property and the care of any minor children. If you die without a will, those wishes may not be carried out. In other words: Your will is the formal document that sets out what is to happen to your property and assets when you die. It is a legal document that is official binding on your executors – which means that they don’t have any choice whether or not to follow it.

Section 2(h) of the Indian Succession Act 1925 provides that will means the legal declaration of the intention of a person with respect of his property, which he desires to take effect after his death will have been defined in corpus juris secundum as A ‘WILL’ is the legal document of a man’s intention, which he will be performed after his death or an instrument by which a person makes disposition of his property to take effect after his death.

The origin and development of Will among the Hindus is unknown. Anyway, Wills was notable to the Mohammedans and contact with them during the Mohammedan standard, and later on, with the European nations, was most likely answerable for the act of subbing casual composed or oral testamentary instruments with formal testamentary instruments. The Indian Succession Act, 1925, solidifying the laws of an intestate (with specific exemptions) and testamentary progression supplants the previous Acts and is appropriate to all the Wills and additions of Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs, and Jain’s all through India. The Indian Succession Act, 1925, doesn’t administer Mohammedans and they can arrange their property as per Muslim Law


*The testator should sign or attach his imprint (e.g., thumb mark).

*The Will must be bore witness to by at least 2 observers.

*The witnesses must have seen the testator sign or append his imprint to the Will.

*Each witness will sign the Will within the sight of the testator.


According to Section 59 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, the person must be

1) Age

2) Sound mind

Besides, the area expresses that an individual usually of the unsound psyche may make a Will during the time-span of the soundness of his/her mind. The segment denies an individual from making a Will when in a condition of inebriation or illness which makes him/ her unequipped for understanding the results of the act.


According to the Indian Succession Act, 1925 there is two types of will.

A. Privileged will

B. Unprivileged Will


Privileged Will

Indian Succession Act, 1925 gives certain benefits to a soldier, a pilot, and a sailor adrift utilized in an undertaking or engaged in actual warfare. These benefits are ordered remembering the problem a soldier is in during the residency of his administration. Arrangements relating to such benefits are referenced under Section 66[2] of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, and such wills are called Privileged Wills.


Unprivileged Will

 Wills created by a testator not being a soldier is known as Unprivileged Wills these wills are generally created by the masses. Unprivileged Wills are governed under section 63[5] of the Indian Succession Act, 1925.



In a will the following details are to be included:

• Details of the testator– The name, age, address, etc which will help in recognizing who is making the will and when is it being drawn.

• Declaration– Significantly, the testator proclaims that he/she is of the sound brain and liberated from any pressure while drawing the will.

• The executor of the will– The details of who will profit out of this will and to whom shall the assets be divided should be given as their name, age, address, and connection to the testator.

• Details of the beneficiary– It is essential to appoint an agent who might guarantee that the will is done by the testator. The name, age, address, and connection to the testator should be specified as well.

• Details of property and assets – It is relevant to details of the assets and properties that a testator has, and which are the ones that will be canvassed in the will. He/she can likewise drill down a particular resource that is there.

• Division of share – The offer that every recipient has on the property or the points of interest of who will persuade what is to be recorded in full detail. On the off chance that the advantage is to be given to a minor, at that point a caretaker for the minor ought to likewise be recorded in the will.

• Specific Directions – The testator should give headings as far as executing the Will and should be determined if there are any guidelines.

• Witness – There should be a mark by the testator within the presence of in any event 2 observers. The observers don’t have to know the detail of the will they simply need to check that the mark by the testator was done before them.

• Signature– The testator should sign with the date on the will after the last explanation.


A Will report stays substantial forever with definitely no time bar for its arrangements to become effective. Anyway as Tarun Mehta has said – a Will can be tested inside 12 years from the date of the passing of the individual. Anyway, the Supreme Court governed in Jamnadas v. Naveen Thakral and Ors. (2007) that if there are reasons with regards to why a few gatherings might not have known about the will for quite a while then the multi-year breaking point might be postponed by the Civil appointed authority as characteristic equity might be influenced something else.

So today – the legitimacy for testing a will – is 12 years from the date on which the will was made open or the date from which the information on the wellbeing in presence could be sensibly expected.


The WILL can be a challenge on these grounds

• Presence of coercion, fraud, or undue influence- The Will should not be prepared by the testator under the presence of these elements then it tends to be taken to be a ground for testing the legitimacy of the Will.

• Presence of a suspicious nature- There might be a presence of specific components in the Will which could give a sensible understanding that there was some offense with it.

• Absence of testamentary intention or capacity- This implies the Will may not delineate an aim for the deceased benefactor to do the Will or execute it. Absence of testamentary limit infers that the departed benefactor probably won’t be of sound and  No proper execution-If the signature of the testator alongside those of the two witnesses is absent then it very well may be a ground to challenge the legitimacy of the Will.

• Absence of knowledge- If the testator didn’t know about marking the Will then it tends to be taken to be a ground for testing the legitimacy of the Will.

• Revocation of Will: claim by family members- A family member can challenge a will because they were not accommodated enough in the will. The law expresses that the top of a family is answerable for the best possible support of certain nearby relatives who are determined in the Hindu Succession Act. On the off chance that a legitimate arrangement isn’t made for these individuals in the will, or they are not enough accommodated by the laws of intestacy, they can make a case in the Family Court or the High Court requesting arrangement to be made for them out of the home.


For beginning the procedure of execution of the will, a Probate in India should be obtained from the court. A Probate of will is a legitimate confirmation of the validity of the will. It tends to be acquired by documenting an appeal under the watchful eye of the court alongside a calendar of the property and adding a duplicate of the will to the request also. It ought to be explicitly appealed to the court to concede probate to complete the aim of the testator

“A will needs to be drafted by taking into consideration the implications that shall follow the beneficiaries and it is better to keep the beneficiaries informed of the same,” says Advocate Koonal Tanwar.

“A proper method of preserving the will can be done by ensuring that it is registered as it would give it a two-fold benefit, one of having a documentary presence and two of ensuring the legal validity over an unregistered Will,” adds Advocate Koonal.

What are the rules governing the transfer of a property through a will?

In the Indian Legal scenario, the laws governing the transfer of property through a will can be seen through these legislations,

• The Indian Succession Act, 1925

• The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908

• The Indian Registration Act, 1908

• The Indian Stamp Act, 1899

3 Thoughts to “Challenging The Validity Of The Will”

  1. Abhishek

    You have done a remarkable job brother. It’s your initial step towards your goal.. Stay focused and determined. God bless you

  2. subbudu

    Good info.
    By the way can you send me a soft copy of the supreme court decision “Jamnadas vs Naveen Thakral & ors (2007). My mail ID :

  3. Sandarsh

    Remarkable work. Knowledge is infinite.
    May you achieve more success on your future path.

Leave a Comment